Four Musical Minimalists: La Monte Young, Terry Riley, Steve Reich, Philip Glass (Music in the Twentieth Century) [Hardcover] Review

Potter's book will be best appreciated by those with a much better understanding of music theory than I.However, I learned something about the personal and musical history of so-called "minimalism."(Potter falls prey to some extent to the problem of reifying an abstraction -- having first grouped some things together into a category, then searching for the true meaning of the category.)Is there a torch passed, so to speak, from Young to Riley to Reich to Glass?Glass is the only one to adamantly deny it, but Potter documents the basis for seeing it just that way (including Reich's influence on Glass).

One aspect I am keen to know more about, but which Potter doesn't stress overly much, is the striking confluence of non-Western influences.Young and Riley are both disciples of the North Indian master singer, Pandit Pran Nath, who died in 1996.Reich studied both African drumming as well as the gamelan music of Bali.Glass studied Indian music, after being immersed in serialism.With the European "classical" tradition at an impasse at the turn of the millennium, it seems only natural that the future would lie in creative fusions and combinationswith other traditions.(Not a very original idea, I realize, as evidenced by the recent emphasis of the Kronos Quartet among others.)Minimalism seems by now to be another style that passed into history and critical assessments -- is there an opening there that is being missed?

Click Here to see more reviews about: Four Musical Minimalists: La Monte Young, Terry Riley, Steve Reich, Philip Glass (Music in the Twentieth Century) [Hardcover]

Product Description:
This book offers the most detailed account so far of the early works of these four minimalist composers, putting extensive discussion of the music into a biographical perspective. The true musical minimalism of the 1960s and early 1970s is placed in the wider context of their music as a whole, and considered within the cultural conditions of the period, which saw not only the rise of minimalism in the fine arts but also crucial changes in the theory and practice of musical composition in the Western cultivated tradition.

Buy cheap Four Musical Minimalists: La Monte Young, Terry Riley, Steve Reich, Philip Glass (Music in the Twentieth Century) [Hardcover] now

The Ambient Century: From Mahler to Moby--The Evolution of Sound in the Electronic Age [Paperback] Review

Your evaluation of THE AMBIENT CENTURY will depend on what you're looking for.I expected serious analysis, and by that criteria would give it 1 star.If what you're interested in, though, is an eclectic encyclopedia of interesting 20th century musicians, loosely grouped by the theme of "ambience," which is never defined, then you might think this is great.(I can't comment on the fact-checking criticism, but to me it's a secondary point.)Prendergast moves from "high art" composers including Debussy and Stockhausen, to "minimalism," to rock, broken into categories such as psychedelic, krautrock and synthesizer music, to the '90s techno/house/drum&bass/ambient trend.

However, his definition of "ambient" involves "music being deconstructed" by Mahler and Debussy (sounds really "postmodern," but what does it mean?), and developments in technology/electronics, along with an "interest in pure sound."He pronounces:"[T]he bleeding heart of electronic progress had by its very nature rendered all recorded music, by definition, Ambient." (4)Given this sort of cosmic perspective Prendergast could have included all music, and what he does include seems to be more or less "cool stuff that I like."Harsh, I know, but does Bob Dylan's "Knocking on Heaven's Door," by any stretch of the conceptual imagination, belong on a list of the Essential 100 Recordings of 20th Century Ambient Music?If so, our author fails to offer any explanation.How about Led Zeppelin IV (ie, ZOSO)?I'm at a loss.

If the book was appropriately titled, I would have much less to criticize.But when you title a book "The Evolution of Sound in the Electronic Age," you lead the reader to expect some sort of theoretical analysis -- what sort of evolution?In what direction?What mechanisms are involved?But there is "no there there" if what is happening is just technological progress, and "an interest in pure sound" may characterize Cage's famous *4'33"* (the silent composition), but there is not even an attempt here to argue that it is the direction of 20th century music.If Prendergast really means to emphasize the use of music as background, where is his discussion of Muzak, and music in advertising?He doesn't develop his embryonic theme(s), but rather rushes headlong into profiles of musicians, which are strung together with little connecting analysis.

Caveat emptor -- if you're looking for serious analysis, look elsewhere, but if you want a breezy journalistic encyclopedia of non-mainstream music (that is seen as cool by The Wire magazine) you might find this a useful reference work.(For a model of analysis of cutting edge music, check out Nyman's EXPERIMENTAL MUSIC.It also has a foreward by Brian Eno!)

Click Here to see more reviews about: The Ambient Century: From Mahler to Moby--The Evolution of Sound in the Electronic Age [Paperback]



Buy cheap The Ambient Century: From Mahler to Moby--The Evolution of Sound in the Electronic Age [Paperback] now

Aesthetics and Music (Continuum Aesthetics) [Paperback] Review

The aesthetics of music is an underserved field.Roger Scruton's "Aesthetics of Music" is a formidable achievement, and perhaps so imposing that few have attempted to update it or even tread on the same territory.Andy Hamilton's "Aesthetics and Music" not only dares to engage Scruton, but does so convincingly and with a clarity not often seen in music scholarship.The strength of the book is its attention to the simplest, most important questions we can ask about music: What is it? Is it distinct from mere sound, and if so, how?Hamilton's book should be required reading for all musicologists and music scholars.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Aesthetics and Music (Continuum Aesthetics) [Paperback]

Product Description:
"The Continuum Aesthetics" series looks at the aesthetic questions and issues raised by all major art forms. Stimulating, engaging and accessible, the series offers food for thought not only for students of aesthetics, but also for anyone with an interest in philosophy and the arts. "Aesthetics and Music" is a fresh and often provocative exploration of the key concepts and arguments in musical aesthetics. It draws on the rich heritage of the subject, while proposing distinctive new ways of thinking about music as an art form. The book looks at: the experience of listening; rhythm and musical movement; what modernism has meant for musical aesthetics; the relation of music to other 'sound arts'; improvisation and composition; as well as more traditional issues in musical aesthetics, such as absolute versus programme music and the question of musical formalism. Thinkers discussed range from Pythagoras and Plato to Kant, Nietzsche and Adorno. Areas of music covered include classical, popular and traditional music, and jazz. "Aesthetics and Music" makes an eloquent case for a humanistic, democratic and genuinely aesthetic conception of music and musical understanding.Anyone interested in what contemporary philosophy has to say about music as an art form will find this thought-provoking and highly enjoyable book required reading.

Buy cheap Aesthetics and Music (Continuum Aesthetics) [Paperback] now